An employee wants to work through lunch and finish early. Their manager agrees, and the work gets done. It seems like a straightforward arrangement, but is it compliant with the employee’s workplace entitlements?
As discussed in HR Leader’s article featuring commentary from Patrick Will, the question of delayed lunch breaks raises important considerations for employers around workplace flexibility, meal break requirements and employee wellbeing.
For HR teams, the challenge is finding the balance between accommodating employees and ensuring workplace arrangements meet the requirements that apply to them.
Flexibility has its limits
In Australia, meal break requirements can vary depending on the applicable modern award, enterprise agreement and employment circumstances. Employers should not assume that an employee and their manager can agree to any arrangement simply because it suits both parties.
Before approving a request to delay a meal break or leave early, HR should check the relevant requirements, including when breaks must be taken and whether flexibility is permitted.
It’s also important to distinguish between changing the timing of a break and routinely working through lunch. These situations may have different implications and should be assessed according to the employee’s applicable entitlements.
The Fair Work Ombudsman provides guidance on workplace break requirements.
When missed breaks point to a bigger problem
An occasional request for flexibility is different from a recurring pattern of employees missing or delaying breaks because they cannot manage their workload.
If employees regularly work through lunch, HR should look beyond the immediate scheduling issue. Meeting-heavy calendars, staffing pressures and unrealistic workloads may be contributing factors.
These patterns can also raise questions about how work is organised and whether employees can take appropriate breaks during the working day.
Rather than treating every occurrence as an isolated incident, HR should work with managers to understand why it is happening and whether changes to workloads, scheduling or team practices are needed.
What should HR do?
Employers can take three practical steps:
- Check the requirements: Confirm the meal break provisions that apply to employees before approving alternative arrangements.
- Give managers clear guidance: Establish when requests can be accommodated and when HR advice is needed.
- Look for recurring patterns: Investigate whether delayed or missed breaks reflect workload pressures or wider workplace practices.
The goal is not to discourage flexibility. It is to ensure that arrangements are compliant, consistently managed and sustainable for employees.
Ultimately, if employees regularly cannot take their breaks, the question for HR is not just when they eat lunch, but why they cannot take it in the first place.
Related reading
Featured in HR Leader:
Saving your lunch break for the end of the day? Here’s what HR has to say
Need help navigating HR in your business?
Get practical advice tailored to your team and stage of growth.
